We tried a lot of diaper bags. A LOT. This is the only one that didn't get returned- I'll compare all the bags we tried.This one (HSD backpack)Pros: Big bag, backpack style. Useful exterior pockets, and a "drawbridge" style opening for the main compartment. It opens all the way up so you can view the contents like a suitcase- this was the main reason why this bag is a winner. Other backpack style diaper bags things get lost in the bottomless pit of the main compartment since they just zip open halfway. This one opens fully and still has side pockets! There are 2 insulated fully closing bottle pockets.Cons: Very tactical look. Maybe a pro for you if you're into that styling :) If not, there is a velcro patch that you can purchase "morale badges" for (look them up on Amazon and there are tons of options) to customize the look a bit. The wipe compartment is difficult to load, but it does hold large packs of wipes. Very few pockets in the main compartment. Included changing pad is very thick and takes up a lot of space. We swapped it for the pad that was included with our original diaper bag to free up the main compartment space.Baby Brezza LuciaPros: Very cool 2 compartment design. Medical bag style opening upper and a diaper caddy in the bottom compartment. Nice looking bag, and lots of pockets in the upper main compartment. Fully enclosed insulated bottle pocket.Cons: When fully loaded, we found the zippers difficult to do up. No easy access wipe pocket, and even though the bottle pocket is sized for 2 bottles we could only fit one while fully loaded.Bern Diaper BackpackPros: Honestly a nice backpack, would have utility after its life as a diaper bag. Decent number of pockets. Cool concept with a larger detachable cooler bag.Cons: Bottomless pit main compartment, cooler bag covers convenient wipe pocket (which isn't too convenient, the pocket is deep enough that the wipe package opening doesn't line up with the zipper), and no good bottle storage without the detachable coolerSkip Hop WeekenderPro: Nice bag, very big! Comes with packing cubes for organization.Cons: Plastic connection points for shoulder strap (not sure how durable), feels like there aren't enough pockets for organization in the main compartment. No convenient access wipe pocket, and the drawbridge opening doesn't drop fully. It's basically a little suitcase, so only being able to open the suitcase 3/4 isn't my favorite. It's a nice bag, but feels pricey for the features.Hritok Diaper bag totePros: Good looking bag, good organization pocketsCons: Not very large at all and insulated pockets are not fully enclosed. Good for if you only carry the essentials. No wipe pocket.Lekebaby Diaper Bag TotePros: Decent size, super cute! Has a separate bottom compartment. Decent number of interior pockets for organization.Cons: Very floppy bag that will not stand up on its own unless packed full. Not fully enclosed insulating bottle pockets. Wipe pocket is meh.Petunia Pickle Bottom PivotPros: Cute style, very nice quality! Very nice conversion from backpack to tote. Separate bottom pocket. Nice insulated bottle pockets.Cons: No dedicated wipe pocket, main compartment will be bottomless pit. We couldn't justify price for utility, but it is a very cute bag that could be great if you carry essentials and don't mind non-easy access wipes. It's really great quality.Jujube Dr BFFPros: Nice quality, convertible tote/backpack, no bottomless pit.Cons: No easy access wipes, no fully enclosed insulated bottle pocket.Fisher Price KadenPros: Good pockets- dedicated bottle pocket and wipe pocket, fully opens to see everything in the main comparment.Cons: We like to have a all in one diaper change pocket, and the large insulated pocket would have been the one we wanted to use for diapers. Personal preference only- this is a good bag and we almost stuck with it.Eddie Bauer Cascade (this was our OG diaper bag, the one we had before we started the quest for a better bag)Pros: Good number of pockets, dedicated wipe pocket, fully enclosed insulated bottle pocketCons: Bottomless pit main compartment, difficult to fit two bottles in the insulated bottle pocket. We stored snacks in the exterior flap pocket and it would tip the bag if we didn't have enough in the main compartment.